Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (2022)

Sam Kmack

The debate around permanently nixing Tucson’s transit fares has heated up once again, with local bus drivers calling for an end to the pricey policy that they say breeds crime, and city officials locking horns over the best way forward with only a month left to make a decision.

Council members have mulled the idea of a fare-free transit system since 2020, when they paused fare collection as a COVID-19 relief measure. The policy applied to the entire system — city buses, the streetcar and Sun Van — and will expire in June unless council members extend it.

Eliminating fares forever would cost local taxpayers anywhere between $800,000 and $1 million each month, while saving the typical rider about $40 in that same timeframe — but it’s not the cost-benefit that has local bus drivers worried.

Tucson’s Teamster union released a letter May 1 asking for an end to the policy, which it blames for the recent spike in crime on routes. Assaults on drivers and riders tripled between 2019 and 2021 — from 21 to 64 — while the number of vandalism incidents increased to 146, more than double what it was before fares were paused.

People are also reading…

“I literally saw a guy pull down his pants and poop on the bench that our passengers are supposed to be sitting on,” said union representative Rebecca Hepburn at a city transit meeting, who added that she was recently hospitalized after being exposed to drugs on her route. “It’s gotten way out of hand.”

Hepburn described the union’s letter opposing a fare-free system as a “cry for help” and said the issue will get far worse this summer, when homeless activity on the buses — the main factor creating the unsafe conditions, according to the union — is expected to skyrocket as people look for ways to escape the heat.

“Gone are (typical riders), replaced by an ever-increasing number of unhoused and displaced individuals,” the union’s letter read. “We have become a mobile refuge from the elements, frequented by drug users, the mentally ill and violent offenders that have made Sun Tran unsafe to ride.”

Pushing everyday riders away

The condition of Tucson’s transit system raises other questions about how it might impact the quality of service for everyday riders. City figures show that bus ridership is still down about 10% compared to what it was before the pandemic.

That’s slightly better than 2021, when about 12.2 million people rode the bus — 12% fewer than in 2019 — but city and union officials insist the “unsafe” conditions are still driving people away, especially given how much the pandemic has waned since last year.

“I’ve spoken with Sun Tran management and they confirmed that we’re driving discretionary riders away, we’re losing drivers as a result of some of the behavioral things that we’re seeing on the buses,” Councilman Steve Kozachik said. “There have been riders who need to use the bus saying simply, ‘this is over the top.’”

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (1)

The ongoing security issues might also throw a wrench in the city’s funding plans for a fare-free system.

Officials have discussed partnering with local school districts to help cover the $9 million to $12 million loss in fare revenue, for example. The idea is that students can use city buses to get to school, so their districts should contribute to help cover costs.

Six months ago council members like Nikki Lee admitted that the buses needed to be made safer before those partnerships could happen, saying “I think that’s really important, especially if we’re going to talk to school districts and those synergies that could be achieved, that we’re really also integrating security into that.”

But the situation hasn’t improved much since then, according to union officials who wrote that there’s still only one security “rover” to cover the entire network and that transit supervisors aren’t instructed to help when they see a driver being attacked.

“(It makes) it nearly impossible for a driver to get much needed assistance when security issues arise,” the union wrote.

(Video) Violence on L.A. public transportation a growing problem

Loss of drivers may spell more trouble

Hepburn said the city has lost a large number of drivers as a result of those issues, a problem made worse by recruiting difficulties that the union says has also stemmed from the crime situation. Fewer drivers means existing workers need to “pick up the slack,” become burnt-out and quit without any new workers available to fill their position.

The cycle of understaffing has played out in many city offices over the past year and can even have an impact on services like Sun Van — a transit option for disabled residents who can’t ride normal buses — that aren’t directly impacted by the crime spike.

“We have about 350 drivers right now, and it’s pretty scary. We had a whole lot more beforehand,” she said. “A lot of other drivers kind of had to pick up the slack (and) they pulled runs in order to keep the city afloat during the pandemic.”

Sun Van has lost 53 employees or about 30% of its drivers since 2019, though its ridership is down by only about 17% and growing faster than any other transit service except for the streetcar. Nearly 50% more people used Sun Van this March than they did last March, for example, and that trend has been ongoing since at least January.

The staffing problem on Sun Van could also create bigger issues for the city. Federal anti-discrimination laws require Tucson to provide an “equivalent (transit) service to individuals with disabilities,” which includes picking them up within 15 minutes of their scheduled ride.

About 96% of Sun Van rides met that standard before the pandemic. City data shows that figure has dropped by eight percentage points since then.

If the number of drivers remains the same while ridership continues to increase — something that could be more likely with a permanent fare-free system — on-time pick-up rates may continue to tank, pushing Tucson out of compliance with federal disability laws.

“I certainly see the benefit of (fare-free transit), but I also see there are challenges with it,” said Sam Credio, Tucson’s new transportation director. “I think the best thing we can do as staff is provide the mayor and council with the best information to help them make an informed decision.”

One month to make a decision

That decision has to be made by June 7, the due date for next year’s budget that needs to include millions for a fare-free system if council members choose to adopt that policy.

There are three main options on the table at this point: keeping transit free, going back to pre-pandemic fare collection, or issuing free transit passes for low-income residents while still requiring others to pay.

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (2)

Fully returning to fare collection seems to be the least popular option on the council, though eliminating fares completely has received support from officials including Mayor Regina Romero and Vice Mayor Lane Santa Cruz — perhaps the most outspoken proponent of that policy.

“The safety-related problems that are being brought up were in place prior to the pandemic,” Santa Cruz said at Tuesday’s council meeting, despite the marked increase in those incidents since 2019. “I think public transit is a public service and I could argue that there are people who can afford to pay for police to respond to calls. But it’s a public service, it’s a public need, so we pay for it with our taxes.”

Going fare-free would make it easier for impoverished Tucsonans to get around town and could be an environmentally-friendly option if it reduces the number of cars on the road.

Fare revenue will never fully cover the cost of operating the transit system, either: the city has been spending tens-of-millions to subsidize the system for decades, so charging people to ride the bus won’t eliminate costs.

But other officials said the third option, which involves giving some free rides but charging those who can afford to pay, could save millions that would otherwise be taken out of the general fund.

“When we instituted the fare-free buses we were playing with house money, that was all done with federal dollars, and we’re now losing about $9 million at the farebox,” Kozachik said. “My proposal is not going to recoup all $9 million, but wouldn’t it be nice to get $4 million back? We can do that without hurting the people who absolutely need free transit.”

Kozachik’s plan was also supported by the bus driver’s union, which suggested in its recent letter that the passes could be handed out at places like libraries and grocery stores.

It’s unclear how much it would cost to install card readers on all city buses, but the union believes it could combat crime by making it easier to identify those who misbehave on the bus.

Using “tokens” that can serve as free passes without having to invest in card-scanning systems was another option mentioned by Kozachik, who added that passes could be handed out at drug treatment facilities to ensure that homeless people still benefit from the program.

(Video) Watch NBC News NOW Live - September 4

“If someone’s not engaged in a program where they can get these passes, that’s not the person who’s presenting themselves at a treatment facility or at a transit center getting the free card,” he said. “The guy getting on the bus who’s strung out and causing the problems is not the one who’s actively engaged in a treatment program.”

Officials have to make their decision during one of the next two council meetings. Even after that vote is taken, the city will have to address the driver shortage, which may be a longer-term issue.

Photos: J.C. Penney stores in Tucson

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (4)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (5)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (6)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (7)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (8)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (9)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (10)

(Video) Watch NBC News NOW Live - July 22

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (11)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (13)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (14)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (15)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (16)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (17)

(Video) Governing Board Monthly Meeting - May 12, 2022

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (18)

J.C. Penney in Tucson

Bus drivers say 'lawlessness abounds' on fare-free Tucson transit system (19)

Tags

  • Transit
  • City Budget
  • Sun Tran
  • Free Fares
  • Lane Santa Cruz
  • Steve Kozachik
  • Tucson Transit
  • Local-government

Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community.

Get local news delivered to your inbox!

FAQs

Are the buses still free in Tucson 2022? ›

The Tucson city council voted unanimously Tuesday to keep rides on Sun Tran buses and street cars free through June 2022. The council scrapped fares at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, using federal relief funds. But fares were set to go back into effect at the end of 2021.

Are the buses still free in Tucson AZ? ›

TUCSON, Ariz. (KOLD News 13) - Tucson city leaders voted to extend free fares through the end of 2022 at a meeting on Tuesday, June 7, Sun Tran announced. The extension was included in the city's budget for fiscal year 2023. The city stopped charging for rides in 2020, when the COVID-19 pandemic hit.

What is the argument supporting free transportation? ›

Free public transport would reduce the number of cars on the road. Global warming is a serious issue and if public transport was free, more people would use it, taking cars off the road. 1 train could take 2000 cars off the road.

How much is it to take a bus in Tucson? ›

What are the most popular bus routes to Tucson?
Daily BusesAverage price
Buses from Tucson to Nogales10$20
Buses from Tucson to Flagstaff3$46
Buses from Tucson to Mesa3$28
Buses from Tucson to Tempe10$10
1 more row

Is public transportation free in Tucson? ›

Tucson public transit to remain free.

How much is a monthly bus pass in Tucson? ›

Regular Monthly Pass: – $42. Express Pass – $56.

Is Tucson sunlink free? ›

The transit service began offering free rides on Sun Tran, Sun Link, Sun Van, Sun on Demand and Sun Shuttle services beginning in March 2020 because of the pandemic.

Is the Tucson Streetcar free? ›

The streetcar is located within walking distance of Tucson's most iconic restaurants, hotels, museums, shops and entertainment venues. Fares are currently free!

Does Tucson have public transportation? ›

Sun Tran, Sun Express, Sun Link, Sun Van, Sun On Demand and Sun Shuttle make up the seamless transit system in Tucson and surrounding areas. Passengers can transfer between the various transit systems using a SunGO card.

Why should public transit be free? ›

By making public transport free, the Government would be encouraging people to use public transport instead of driving to and from work. Whilst there may be the initial lack of revenue from the ticket prices, the Government would benefit the environment.

Why should public transport be free debate? ›

The promise of free public transport is an enticing one: fewer cars, less congestion, less pollution. And a greater sense of community, says Judith Dellheim from Berlin's Rosa Luxemburg Foundation. "It could make the cities more human and more attractive," she says.

What are advantages and disadvantages of using public transport? ›

Top 10 Public Transportation Pros & Cons – Summary List
Public Transport ProsPublic Transport Cons
Fewer traffic jamsDetours may be difficult
Opportunity to meet new peopleNavigation problems
Good for touristsLess convenient compared to cars
Good alternative for older peopleTransport of heavy items is a problem
6 more rows

How much is the bus from Tucson to Las Vegas? ›

Bus tickets between Las Vegas and Tucson cost $69.99 on average, but you can get tickets for as low as $64.99 if you book in advance and/or outside of busy travel times, like weekends and holidays.

How much is a shuttle from Tucson to Phoenix? ›

TUCSON FARES
To / From PHX Airport:ONLINE DISCOUNT AdultsAdult
Tucson$49.00$54.00
Home Pick-Up / Drop-Off*Additional $15-$32 per reservation, based on distance.

What time does the bus run in Tucson? ›

1 bus Schedule
DayOperating HoursFrequency
Sunday7:44 AM - 7:44 PM1 hr
Monday5:37 AM - 10:12 PM30 min
Tuesday5:37 AM - 10:12 PM30 min
Wednesday5:37 AM - 10:12 PM30 min
3 more rows

How do you get around Tucson without a car? ›

Bus Service within Tucson

Tucson's Sun Tran bus service offers more than 40 routes throughout the city and its outskirts, including 13 express routes. Learn more online or call (520) 792-9222 for route maps and schedules.

Are buses free right now in Phoenix AZ? ›

The Phoenix Public Transit Department is distributing free transit passes for people in need and it's proving to be a huge help to underserved communities.

Do you need a car in Tucson Arizona? ›

Tucson has a reputation for being extremely livable without owning a vehicle. However, this isn't true for the entire metropolitan area. Some parts of Tucson are ideal for living a car-less life, while others will still require motorized transportation. Fortunately, most of Tucson is considered bike-able.

How much is the bus fare in Phoenix AZ? ›

The one-way cost is $2.00 for local bus and an All-Day pass is $4.00. The one-way cost is $3.25 for RAPID and Express buses and $6.50 for an All-Day pass. Many employers offer discount bus passes or you can buy a monthly pass at one of the transit centers. The fare box is located at the front of the bus.

How often does the sunlink run? ›

Thursday & Friday
TimesFrequency
7AM – 9AMEvery 15 Min.
9AM – 6PMEvery 10 Min.
6PM – 12AMEvery 15 Min.
12AM – 2AMEvery 30 Min.

How do you signal to get off a bus? ›

To get off the bus, signal the driver one block before your stop by pulling the cord or pressing the yellow strip. This will ring a bell and light the “stop requested” signal for the driver.

How large is Tucson? ›

Which city has best public transportation? ›

The company ranked Seattle number one when comparing transit systems across 100 cities in the U.S. based on accessibility, convenience, safety, reliability, and available resources.

Is public transport a public good? ›

For a good to be a public good, it must be nonexcludable and nonrival. So, for example, public transportation is not a public good. It is excludable, because the transit company won't give you a ride if you don't pay the fare.

Is making public transport free a good idea? ›

Free public transport may not be effective for making transport sustainable on its own, but it can have plenty of other benefits that make it worthwhile. It can be a progressive social policy, guaranteeing and improving access to public transport for diverse groups that might otherwise struggle to get around.

What country has free public transport? ›

On 29 February 2020, Luxembourg became the first country in the world to make all public transport in the country (buses, trams, and trains) free to use.

Is public transportation a human right? ›

The right to freedom of movement precedes the U.S. Constitution and is enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: It's not merely a human right, it's the foundation of a healthy economy.

Why do we need more public transportation? ›

Public transportation contributes to a healthier environment by improving air quality and reducing oil consumption, and through better land-use policies. It also helps to expand business development and work opportunities. And, it is critical for emergency situations requiring safe and efficient evacuation.

Why is public transport good for the environment? ›

Environmental benefits

Travel by public transport instead of cars and planes reduces greenhouse gases which contribute to climate change. Public transport also reduces our reliance on precious natural resources such as oil and the land we use for road infrastructure and car parks.

What are the advantages of using public transportation essay? ›

8 Benefits of Public Transportation
  • Improves Community Health. ...
  • Economic Benefits to the Community. ...
  • Improves Fuel Efficiency. ...
  • Public Transportation Reduces Air Pollution. ...
  • Improves Road Congestion. ...
  • Improves Community Mobility. ...
  • Provides an Equitable Transportation System. ...
  • Public Transportation Improves Commuters Productivity.
Jan 25, 2021

Why we should use public transport essay? ›

Encouraging people to use public transport is a good way to reduce pollution and other traffic problems. If better public transport facilities will be made available it will discourage use of individual vehicles. That will also help in saving time, energy, money and other resources.

Videos

1. Night
(Minhwan Kim)
2. PBS NewsHour West live episode, Jan. 21, 2022
(PBS NewsHour)
3. Jen Psaki speaks to reporters on Biden's first anniversary in office | full video
(CBS News)
4. Biden to call European allies over Ukraine
(Sky News Australia)
5. Full Panel: White House Plans A 'Reset In Messaging' For Biden's Second Year
(NBC News)
6. Biden laughs off question that he 'overpromised' in first year as president
(Sky News Australia)

You might also like

Latest Posts

Article information

Author: Arline Emard IV

Last Updated: 07/18/2022

Views: 5620

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arline Emard IV

Birthday: 1996-07-10

Address: 8912 Hintz Shore, West Louie, AZ 69363-0747

Phone: +13454700762376

Job: Administration Technician

Hobby: Paintball, Horseback riding, Cycling, Running, Macrame, Playing musical instruments, Soapmaking

Introduction: My name is Arline Emard IV, I am a cheerful, gorgeous, colorful, joyous, excited, super, inquisitive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.